The Complete Guide to Choosing the Perfect Exterior Door for Your Home

Selecting a new front door can be a daunting task. We are here to help!

Presented by Winston Builders

Choosing the right exterior door is more than just a matter of curb appeal — it's about security, energy efficiency, durability, and creating a welcoming entryway to your home. At Winston Builders, we help our clients make smart, stylish, and long-lasting choices when it comes to new construction and renovation projects. This guide walks you through everything you need to know to select the perfect exterior door for your needs.

1. The Main Types of Exterior Doors

There are three main material types to choose from, each with distinct advantages:

Steel Doors

Pros:

• Extremely strong and secure

• Resistant to warping and cracking

• Most affordable option

• Excellent fire resistance

Cons:

• Can dent or scratch easily

• Poor insulator unless filled with foam core

• Requires a good finish to prevent rust

Best for: Budget-conscious homeowners who prioritize security.

Fiberglass Doors

Pros:

• Can mimic wood grain beautifully

• Highly energy-efficient (great insulation)

• Low maintenance and weather-resistant

• Durable and long-lasting

Cons:

• Slightly more expensive than steel

• Not as naturally strong as wood or steel (but sufficient for most homes)

Best for: Homeowners who want a wood look without the upkeep and great energy efficiency.

Wood Doors

Pros:

• Timeless appearance and character

• Easily customizable with stains, paints, and carvings

• Heavier feel and high-end appeal

Cons:

• Expensive and requires regular maintenance

• Vulnerable to moisture, warping, and insect damage

Best for: Historic or high-end homes where character and customization matter most.

2. Style Considerations: Matching the Door to Your Home

Modern Homes

Look for sleek, minimalist designs with clean lines, large glass panels, or horizontal slats. Steel or fiberglass doors in matte black or neutral tones work well.

Traditional Homes

Opt for classic six-panel doors, half-glass designs, or decorative sidelights. Wood or fiberglass doors with rich stains often complement these homes beautifully.

Farmhouse or Craftsman Style

Consider shaker-style doors, doors with window grids, or plank-style panels. Earthy tones, natural finishes, and solid construction are key.

3. Glass or No Glass?

Adding glass to your door can enhance natural light and aesthetic appeal. But keep in mind:

• Privacy: Frosted or textured glass can prevent visibility while still allowing light.

• Security: Choose impact-resistant or double-glazed glass for better protection.

• Energy Efficiency: Look for insulated or Low-E glass to prevent heat transfer.
  

4. Energy Efficiency & Insulation

The U.S. Department of Energy reports that poorly sealed doors can lead to energy loss. Here’s how to pick an efficient door:

• Look for ENERGY STAR labels

• Check the R-Value (higher is better)

• Opt for foam-core insulation in steel or fiberglass doors

• Ensure quality weatherstripping and installation

• 
  

5. Security Features

An exterior door is your first line of defense. Here are some must-have security features:

• Solid core or reinforced frame

• High-quality deadbolt and lockset

• Smart lock compatibility (optional but convenient)

• Multi-point locking systems (for enhanced reinforcement)

  
  

6. Color and Finish Selection

Your door color sets the tone for your entire exterior. While neutral tones like black, white, and wood stains are timeless, bold colors like navy, red, or teal can make a powerful statement.

Tips:

• Match your door to your trim or contrast with siding

• Use high-quality exterior paint or stain

• Consider UV-resistant finishes for longevity

  
  

7. Don’t Forget the Frame and Hardware

• Frame material: Wood frames are standard but can rot; composite or metal-clad frames are longer-lasting

• Thresholds and weatherstripping: Crucial for energy performance

• Hardware: Handles, knobs, and kick plates can be upgraded for both style and function

  
  

8. Budget Breakdown

Material	Average Cost (Installed)
Steel	$500 - $1,500
Fiberglass	$800 - $3,000
Wood	$1,500 - $5,000+

Note: Customizations, sidelights, and smart locks can increase costs.

Conclusion: What’s the Best Exterior Door for You?

The right door for your home depends on your climate, aesthetic preferences, budget, and maintenance expectations. At Winston Builders, we walk you through every step — from design consultation to professional installation.

Let’s Build a Beautiful First Impression — Together.

Need Help Choosing? Let’s Chat!

Contact Winston Builders for a free design consultation. We'll help you pick the perfect door to match your home, lifestyle, and budget.